Telehealth vs. Traditional Healthcare: Which is Better for Employees?

Telehealth vs. Traditional Healthcare: Which is Better for Employees?
March 8, 2025

The healthcare landscape is undergoing a seismic shift, influenced by the rapid rise of telehealth and the continued reliance on traditional, in-person care. In this transformation, employers face the pressing question: how do they offer the best healthcare options for their employees? While both telehealth and traditional healthcare have their merits, understanding which is most beneficial for employees depends on a mix of accessibility, cost, and employee satisfaction.

As employees increasingly prioritize convenience and flexibility in their healthcare, telehealth services have gained considerable traction. However, traditional healthcare still holds value for certain medical needs, where face-to-face interactions and physical examinations are essential. This article delves into the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches, offering employers insights on how to create a balanced healthcare package that benefits their workforce.

Telehealth: Convenience at Your Fingertips

Telehealth is transforming how employees access healthcare, offering them the convenience of consultations from anywhere, at any time. Telehealth services, which include virtual visits, remote monitoring, and digital health tools, remove many of the obstacles that have traditionally made healthcare less accessible. According to a study by Renew Health, 70% of employees report using telehealth services, citing the convenience and cost-effectiveness of virtual consultations.

One of the key advantages of telehealth is its ability to deliver immediate care. Employees no longer need to take time off work, travel long distances, or endure long wait times at clinics. This is particularly significant as many employees face constraints such as limited time or geographic isolation, making traditional care less feasible. In fact, a Mercer study found that 43% of employees avoid seeking medical help due to time constraints or inconvenience, highlighting telehealth’s role in bridging that gap.

However, telehealth is not without its limitations. While it excels at offering access to basic care, such as consultations for minor illnesses or prescriptions, it may fall short for more complex medical concerns. But for those with relatively simple healthcare needs, telehealth offers a compelling, cost-effective alternative to traditional healthcare.

Traditional Healthcare: The Value of In-Person Care

Despite telehealth’s growing popularity, traditional healthcare continues to hold significant value, especially for more complex medical issues. In-person care allows for physical examinations, hands-on treatment, and the establishment of a more personal relationship between patient and provider. These elements are crucial for certain types of care, such as diagnostic procedures or conditions requiring physical therapy.

According to research published in PMC, face-to-face consultations are often seen as more trustworthy and comprehensive by patients. They allow doctors to physically assess symptoms, perform tests, and provide real-time, direct feedback. For many, the human interaction in a clinical setting offers reassurance and confidence in the care they receive.

Additionally, traditional healthcare settings are equipped to handle emergency situations, complex conditions, and surgeries domains where telehealth simply cannot replace the need for in-person treatment. Although telehealth has made significant advancements in delivering primary care, for high-acuity patients or those requiring hands-on procedures, traditional healthcare remains irreplaceable.

Nevertheless, traditional healthcare is not without its drawbacks. Long wait times, high costs, and limited access in rural areas can make it a less attractive option for some employees. These challenges have prompted employers to explore hybrid models that combine the convenience of telehealth with the comprehensive care provided by in-person visits.

Employee Perspectives: What Do They Prefer?

What do employees actually prefer when it comes to their healthcare options? A survey by Tenovi revealed that 80% of employees appreciate the convenience of telehealth, yet 45% still prefer in-person consultations for more complex issues. This highlights the need for a nuanced approach to employee healthcare one that offers flexibility and accommodates various preferences.

Convenience is the primary factor influencing employee’s choices. Telehealth appeals to employees seeking flexibility, particularly those who struggle to fit in-person visits into their busy schedules. Younger employees, in particular, gravitate toward telehealth for its convenience and technological integration. According to research conducted by Mercer, younger generations, especially millennials and Gen Z, are more likely to use telehealth for everything from consultations to mental health services. For these workers, telehealth offers a solution that aligns with their digital-first lifestyle.

However, many employees still value the human connection that comes with traditional care. Older generations, in particular, tend to trust in-person healthcare providers more and feel more comfortable receiving care in a physical setting. They are more likely to prioritize the personal interaction and hands-on care that traditional healthcare offers, even if it involves longer wait times and higher costs.

As a result, offering a hybrid model that blends both telehealth and traditional care is increasingly becoming the gold standard for employers seeking to meet the diverse needs of their workforce.

Employer’s Role: Adapting to Employee Needs

As the demand for telehealth services rises, employers must adapt by offering healthcare options that suit a range of employee preferences. The question is not whether telehealth or traditional healthcare is better, but how employers can provide both in a way that maximizes benefits for employees while controlling costs.

Employers can integrate telehealth services into their benefits packages to provide employees with convenient, cost-effective care for common medical concerns. For instance, telehealth services can cover virtual consultations for minor illnesses, prescription refills, mental health services, and even remote monitoring of chronic conditions. Offering these services as part of a comprehensive healthcare plan can help employees access the care they need without having to take time off work or deal with the challenges of in-person visits.

At the same time, employers must recognize that certain healthcare needs are best met through traditional care. For more complex medical conditions, in-person visits with specialists may be necessary. Employers can offer coverage for these visits, ensuring that employees have access to the comprehensive care they require. Companies such as Taylor Oswald have successfully implemented hybrid models that allow employees to choose between virtual care and in-person consultations, resulting in increased employee satisfaction and improved health outcomes.

The benefits of a hybrid model are clear. Employees enjoy the convenience of telehealth for minor medical concerns while still having access to the expertise and hands-on care that traditional healthcare provides when needed. For employers, this approach can reduce healthcare costs by shifting more basic care to telehealth while ensuring that employees receive the high-quality care they need for more serious health issues.

Finding the Right Balance

The debate between telehealth and traditional healthcare is not a simple one. Both have distinct advantages, and neither is a one-size-fits-all solution. What matters most is that employers listen to their employees and create healthcare packages that align with their unique needs.

By offering a combination of telehealth and traditional healthcare, employers can ensure that their workforce has access to the care they need, when they need it. Telehealth provides convenience and cost savings, while traditional healthcare offers the depth and personal interaction that some employees require. Striking the right balance between the two will lead to higher employee satisfaction, better health outcomes, and ultimately, a more engaged and productive workforce.

As we look to the future of healthcare, it’s clear that the ability to adapt to changing employee needs will be key to a company’s success. Employers should take a proactive approach to healthcare, regularly evaluating their offerings and ensuring that they provide employees with a wide range of options that meet their diverse preferences and health concerns.

    Disclaimer: The above helpful resources content contains personal opinions and experiences. The information provided is for general knowledge and does not constitute professional advice.

    You may also be interested in: Our Services – RexCare®

    Healthcare gaps are draining your resources and hurting employee well-being. When health issues go untreated, absenteeism rises, and productivity declines. Rexcare offers a budget-friendly solution. For just $20 per employee monthly, give your team 24/7 telemedicine, prescription savings, mental health support, and preventive screenings. No long-term commitments just quality care that keeps your workforce healthy and your business thriving. With Rexcare, employee healthcare on a budget becomes your competitive advantage! Join RexCare today visit rexcare.com or call (833) 33-GO-REX